"Prof. Timothy Williamson (Wykeham Professor of Logic, University of Oxford) pat\u0159\u00ED ji\u017E od dob prvn\u00EDch badatelsk\u00FDch kr\u016F\u010Dk\u016F experiment\u00E1ln\u00ED filosofie (x-phi) k jej\u00EDm nejzaryt\u011Bj\u0161\u00EDm a nejtvrd\u0161\u00EDm kritik\u016Fm. O tom, \u017Ee mu \u010Detn\u00E9 a rozs\u00E1hl\u00E9 odpov\u011Bdi experiment\u00E1ln\u00EDch filosof\u016F na jeho v\u00FDtky nep\u0159ipadaj\u00ED zcela posta\u010Duj\u00EDc\u00ED a jeho nespokojenost s t\u00EDmto v\u00FDzkumn\u00FDm programem nad\u00E1le trv\u00E1, se mohli p\u0159esv\u011Bd\u010Dit i n\u00E1v\u0161t\u011Bvn\u00EDci jeho podzimn\u00EDch trnavsk\u00FDch p\u0159edn\u00E1\u0161ek. Prof. Williamson zde zcela rezolutn\u011B tvrdil, \u017Ee x-phi nem\u016F\u017Ee p\u0159isp\u011Bt k \u0159e\u0161en\u00ED filosofick\u00FDch ot\u00E1zek. R\u00E1d bych s t\u00EDmto tvrzen\u00EDm polemizoval a m\u016Fj p\u0159\u00EDsp\u011Bvek by m\u011Bl slou\u017Eit p\u0159edev\u0161\u00EDm jako jak\u00FDsi korektiv neblah\u00FDch vliv\u016F tzv. schodi\u0161\u0165ov\u00E9ho efektu, j\u00EDm\u017E prof. Krob ozna\u010Duje onu frustruj\u00EDc\u00ED zku\u0161enost, kdy ty nejlep\u0161\u00ED reakce \u010Dlov\u011Bka napadaj\u00ED a\u017E na schodech, po cest\u011B z p\u0159edn\u00E1\u0161kov\u00E9ho s\u00E1lu." . "1"^^ . "56451" . "S" . "RIV/00216224:14210/14:00076136!RIV15-MSM-14210___" . "X-phi a %22tradi\u010Dn\u00ED%22 filosofick\u00E9 ot\u00E1zky: Kontra Williamson"@cs . . . "X-phi a %22tradi\u010Dn\u00ED%22 filosofick\u00E9 ot\u00E1zky: Kontra Williamson" . . "X-phi a %22tradi\u010Dn\u00ED%22 filosofick\u00E9 ot\u00E1zky: Kontra Williamson" . "X-phi and %22Traditional%22 Philosophical Questions: Contra Williamson"@en . . "Since the time of its first steps, Professor Timothy Williamson (Wykeham Professor of Logic, University of Oxford) has been one of the fiercest critics of experimental philosophy (x-phi). The audience at his autumn lectures in Trnava could see for themselves that Professor Williamson is not satisfied with numerous and elaborate responses of experimental philosophers to his criticism and that his discontent with this movement persists. Professor Williamson argued there that x-phi is not able to contribute to the solution of philosophical questions. I would like to doubt this claim and my presentation should be seen mainly as a rehabilitation of unfortunate influences of so-called staircase effect - the term coined by Professor Josef Krob to describe the frustrating situation when the best responses come to the person when he is on his way from the lecturing hall."@en . "epistemic status of intuitions; experimental philosophy; Timothy Williamson"@en . "RIV/00216224:14210/14:00076136" . "X-phi a %22tradi\u010Dn\u00ED%22 filosofick\u00E9 ot\u00E1zky: Kontra Williamson"@cs . "X-phi and %22Traditional%22 Philosophical Questions: Contra Williamson"@en . . . . . "[2FD3D3506843]" . . "1"^^ . . . . "Prof. Timothy Williamson (Wykeham Professor of Logic, University of Oxford) pat\u0159\u00ED ji\u017E od dob prvn\u00EDch badatelsk\u00FDch kr\u016F\u010Dk\u016F experiment\u00E1ln\u00ED filosofie (x-phi) k jej\u00EDm nejzaryt\u011Bj\u0161\u00EDm a nejtvrd\u0161\u00EDm kritik\u016Fm. O tom, \u017Ee mu \u010Detn\u00E9 a rozs\u00E1hl\u00E9 odpov\u011Bdi experiment\u00E1ln\u00EDch filosof\u016F na jeho v\u00FDtky nep\u0159ipadaj\u00ED zcela posta\u010Duj\u00EDc\u00ED a jeho nespokojenost s t\u00EDmto v\u00FDzkumn\u00FDm programem nad\u00E1le trv\u00E1, se mohli p\u0159esv\u011Bd\u010Dit i n\u00E1v\u0161t\u011Bvn\u00EDci jeho podzimn\u00EDch trnavsk\u00FDch p\u0159edn\u00E1\u0161ek. Prof. Williamson zde zcela rezolutn\u011B tvrdil, \u017Ee x-phi nem\u016F\u017Ee p\u0159isp\u011Bt k \u0159e\u0161en\u00ED filosofick\u00FDch ot\u00E1zek. R\u00E1d bych s t\u00EDmto tvrzen\u00EDm polemizoval a m\u016Fj p\u0159\u00EDsp\u011Bvek by m\u011Bl slou\u017Eit p\u0159edev\u0161\u00EDm jako jak\u00FDsi korektiv neblah\u00FDch vliv\u016F tzv. schodi\u0161\u0165ov\u00E9ho efektu, j\u00EDm\u017E prof. Krob ozna\u010Duje onu frustruj\u00EDc\u00ED zku\u0161enost, kdy ty nejlep\u0161\u00ED reakce \u010Dlov\u011Bka napadaj\u00ED a\u017E na schodech, po cest\u011B z p\u0159edn\u00E1\u0161kov\u00E9ho s\u00E1lu."@cs . . "14210" . "Horsk\u00FD, Jan" . .