About: Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal

Facets (new session)
Description
Metadata
Settings
- owl:sameAs
- Inference Rule:

About: Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal Goto Sponge NotDistinct Permalink

An Entity of Type : http://linked.opendata.cz/ontology/domain/vavai/Vysledek, within Data Space : linked.opendata.cz associated with source document(s)

Attributes	Values
rdf:type	skos:Concept http://linked.opendata.cz/ontology/domain/vavai/Vysledek
Description	Nunberg maintains that there are cases like %22I am traditionally entitled to a last meal%22, as uttered by a condemned prisoner facing the firing squad, which suggest that an indexical like 'I' does double duty as a vehicle of singular and general reference. I argue against this claim. My position is that the sentence should be factored out into two: %22Traditionally, a condemned prisoner is entitled to a last meal%22 and %22I am a condemned prisoner%22. Nunberg's sentence is generated by means of an illicit substitution of 'I' for 'a condemned prisoner' inside the scope of 'traditionally'. The morale is that sloppy or literally nonsensical speech like Nunberg's sentence is not suitable as data for logical analysis of natural language. What is suitable data is the two-premise argument I put forward. Nunberg maintains that there are cases like %22I am traditionally entitled to a last meal%22, as uttered by a condemned prisoner facing the firing squad, which suggest that an indexical like 'I' does double duty as a vehicle of singular and general reference. I argue against this claim. My position is that the sentence should be factored out into two: %22Traditionally, a condemned prisoner is entitled to a last meal%22 and %22I am a condemned prisoner%22. Nunberg's sentence is generated by means of an illicit substitution of 'I' for 'a condemned prisoner' inside the scope of 'traditionally'. The morale is that sloppy or literally nonsensical speech like Nunberg's sentence is not suitable as data for logical analysis of natural language. What is suitable data is the two-premise argument I put forward. (en)
Title	Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal (en)
skos:prefLabel	Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal (en)
skos:notation	RIV/67985955:_____/11:00372757!RIV12-AV0-67985955
http://linked.open...avai/riv/aktivita	P Z
http://linked.open...avai/riv/aktivity	P(GAP401/10/0792), Z(AV0Z90090514)
http://linked.open...iv/cisloPeriodika	1
http://linked.open...vai/riv/dodaniDat	2012
http://linked.open...aciTvurceVysledku	Jespersen, Bjorn
http://linked.open.../riv/druhVysledku	J - Článek v odborném periodiku
http://linked.open...iv/duvernostUdaju	S - Úplné a pravdivé údaje nepodléhající ochraně podle zvláštních právních předpisů
http://linked.open...titaPredkladatele	Filosofický ústav AV ČR, v. v. i.
http://linked.open...dnocenehoVysledku	235722
http://linked.open...ai/riv/idVysledku	RIV/67985955:_____/11:00372757
http://linked.open...riv/jazykVysledku	eng - angličtina
http://linked.open.../riv/klicovaSlova	Nunberg; condemned prisoner; indexicals; logical analysis of natural language (en)
http://linked.open.../riv/klicoveSlovo	Nunberg condemned prisoner indexicals logical analysis of natural language
http://linked.open...odStatuVydavatele	SK - Slovenská republika
http://linked.open...ontrolniKodProRIV	[DA7DDCF9757F]
http://linked.open...i/riv/nazevZdroje	Organon F
http://linked.open...in/vavai/riv/obor	AA
http://linked.open...ichTvurcuVysledku	1 (xsd:int)
http://linked.open...cetTvurcuVysledku	1 (xsd:int)
http://linked.open...vavai/riv/projekt	Temporal aspects of knowledge and information
http://linked.open...UplatneniVysledku	2011
http://linked.open...v/svazekPeriodika	18
http://linked.open...iv/tvurceVysledku	Jespersen, Bjorn
http://linked.open...n/vavai/riv/zamer	Transdisciplinary research into selected key areas of philosophy and related disciplines, in particular, logic, classical and medieval studies, and the theory of science. Editions and publications of corresponding texts and electronic databases.
issn	1335-0668
number of pages	9 (xsd:int)

Faceted Search & Find service v1.16.118 as of Jun 21 2024

Alternative Linked Data Documents: ODE Content Formats:

RDF

ODATA

Microdata

About

OpenLink Virtuoso version 07.20.3240 as of Jun 21 2024, on Linux (x86_64-pc-linux-gnu), Single-Server Edition (126 GB total memory, 9 GB memory in use)
Data on this page belongs to its respective rights holders.
Virtuoso Faceted Browser Copyright © 2009-2024 OpenLink Software